Balassa, bela, trade liberalization and revealed comparative advantage. In turkey, the volume of bilateral trade has considerably increased especially following the completion of the customs union cu. Revealed comparative advantage rca index, trade intensity and the spearmans rank coefficient that help to explain the changing patterns of trade specialization of the country. Revealed comparative advantage and the measurement of international competitiveness for agricultural commodities. It was calculated by using the time series data since 1970 2010. The disadvantage of increasing trade liberalization. The adb economics working paper series is a quickdisseminating, informal publication. Changing revealed comparative advantage of textile and clothing 522 trade pattern and conclude that distortion in trade patterns due to inequitable trade barriers are features of rtas. Abstract trade liberalisation over the last two decades in eastern africa has been pronounced, and has resulted in significant increases in exports and imports both through interregional trade and intraregional trade. Hirschman index, effective rate of protection, nominal rate of protection and trade map. There is no consensus in the literature on whether preferential trade agreements help or hinder trade liberalization toward nonmembers. The facilitation of economic integration in a region is. Pdf revealed comparative advantage and competitiveness. Two decades of trade liberalisation and market expansion in eastern africa towards a new economic geography.
This is followed by an analysis of revealed comparative advantage rca in trade between the eu and the two central european countries. The idea to determine a countrys strong sectors by analyzing the actual export flows was pioneered by liesner 1958. The bias in the structure of developing countries protection against southsouth trade 30 i revealed comparative advantage of the south 31 ii souths share in imports 35 iii some inferences 38 iv. The net export index of revealed comparative advantage, is, however, affected by. The paper identifies the pattern of revealed comparative advantage using the balassa 1965 index for export data. The balassa index bi is an important metric in empirical analysis of international trade. On the theoretical interpretation of indices of trade intensity and revealed comparative advantage. Economic growth nexus trade liberalization in ethiopia. The aim of this paper is to identify the sectors in which the republic of macedonia has a comparative advantage in export to the other member states of cefta 2006 central european free trade agreement.
Cepii working paper new revealed comparative advantage index. So most developing countries are focusing in manufactory. Revealed comparative advantage is a key concept in international economics. Further trade liberalization in these areas particularly, by both industrial and developing countries, would help the poorest escape from extreme poverty.
Observed trends indicates that range of products that are being exported from serbia to eu market increased but that. The proposed adjusted index is called revealed symmetric comparative advantage rsca. Trade liberalization and laissezfaire economics are altering the structure of agricultural production and trade. Patterns of canadas revealed comparative advantage in the united states sungchul lee university of regina abstract this paper examines the competitiveness of canada in the united states visavis 31 other major exporters to theu. Revealed comparative advantage of wool and mohair during the study period 2003 to 2012. Data collection and calculations were carried out in the framework of the atlantic trade project, directed by the author and sponsored by the council on foreign relations. Balassa 1965 comparativeadvantage indices measure revealed. The cn4digit trade data is divided into two groups according to whether a country enjoys a revealed comparative advantage in a given market area or not. Since the procedure was refined and popularized by bela balassa 1965, 1989. Pakistan the main shareholder of the pakistans gdp that bear revealed comparative and competitive advantage in. The customs union agreement signed between turkey and the eu that came into force in 1996 has led to a trade liberalisation and increased. Balassa 1965 comparative advantage by sector of industry. Since the procedure was refined and popularized by bela balassa 1965, 1989 it is popularly known as the balassa index. The index has been calculated at the sector and commodity level of the harmonized system of classification.
The writing of this paper was undertaken while the author was a social science research council fellow. Trade liberalization allows countries to specialize in producing the goods and services where they have a comparative advantage produce at lowest opportunity cost. Trade liberalisation allows countries to specialise in producing the goods and services where they have a comparative advantage produce at lowest opportunity cost. The empirical analysis of the present paper is based on revealed comparative advantage rca. The opinions expressed in this paper are his own and do. Revealed comparative advantage in trade between the. Export comparative advantage analysis of iranian hen egg. According to the law of comparative advantage, the policy permits trading partners mutual gains from trade of goods and services ikenson, 2006. The results also revealed that lesotho is specializing with these agricultural commodities in the agricultural industry. Revealed comparative advantage in trade between the republic of macedonia and cefta 2006. An analysis for india and china amita batra zeba khan august 2005 the views expressed in the icrier working paper series are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect those of the indian council for research on. The manchester school of economic and social studies, 1965. Revealed comparative advantages in service trade of the usa, eu, and. Their finding revealed that trade liberalisation does not.
It has been conceived to be useful for three tasks ballance et al. Revealed comparative advantage and the measurement of. Patterns of canadas revealed comparative advantage in the united states sungchul lee university of regina. Richardson and zhang 1999 estimated export patterns variation over time for different sectors and region of usa by using balassa index. Trade liberalisation and revealed comparative advantage1. Global trade liberalization and the developing countries. They found that ethiopia has 302 product lines in which it has revealed comparative advantage, rca equal and greater than 1. The authors have concluded that ethiopia has comparative advantage in 302 products. Findings from the revealed comparative advantage index indicated clearly that lesotho enjoys revealed comparative advantage of wool and mohair during the study period 2003 to 2012. Comparative advantage and export potential of thai. Comparative advantage and export potential of thai vegetable. The sixth is that the revealed comparative advantage profile of the nonmaquila.
The manchester school of economics and social studies, 33, 99123. Would general trade liberalization in developing countries. The impact of trade liberalisation on economic growth in. Balassa b 1965 trade liberalization and revealed comparative advantage the from business bus 410 at business school barcelona. Switzerland is integrated into a global economy to an exceedingly high degree thus making foreign trade an important growth driver for swiss economy. Salaimartin, 2002a, 2002b emphasize that trade liberalization raises the earnings of the poor by increasing longrun. The theoretical discussion focuses on the properties of rsca and empirical evidence, based on the. The manchester school of economic and social studies, 33, 99124. Understanding the nongaussian distribution of revealed. Trade liberalisation and revealed comparative advantage 1. Thus, trade liberalization is now often advanced as a key elementwithin other policies and reforms of any development strategy, and, is considered to be a prime source of convergence to. University of california, san diego august 17, 2007 this report describes the construction of a series of comparative advantage measures for brazilian agriculture, mining and manufacturing sectors between 1986 and 2001. Using the mean as an indicator, canada has high comparative advantage. Balassa b 1965 trade liberalization and revealed comparative.
All seven indices show that turkey has revealed comparative advantages for seven of the 63 product groups. In terms of growth of manufactured exports, mexico has never looked. An analysis for india and china amita batra zeba khan august 2005 the views expressed in the icrier working paper series are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect those of the indian council for research on international economic relations icrier. Market oriented approach of revealed comparative advantage in international trade relative comparative advantage in export is not revealed with the lowest recorded share of 30. Export comparative advantage analysis of iranian hen egg by.
Policy issues related to trade are influenced through research outputs that draw on the concept of comparative advantage of nationsregions. The authors investigated the comparative advantage of ethiopia and the role played by international purchasing. We also have calculated balassas revealed comparative advantage rca index. Trade liberalization and comparative advantage dynamics in. The potential impact of a liberalization of global trade on developing nations is a controversial subject. Trade liberalization, export orientation and employment in. Trade liberalisation leads to removal of tariff barriers and the market. Trade integration and revealed comparative advantages of. The principle of comparative advantage, a classic tenet of economics, is. It computes comparative advantage indicators on the basis of disaggregated trade flow data, and assesses the effects of trade liberalization. Iii measures the revealed comparative advantage of indias industry, categorizes its. The sixth is that the revealed comparative advantage profile of the nonmaquila manufacturing sector shows some peculiar characteristics, which are difficult to interpret from the perspective of mainstream trade theories. The liberalization of global agricultural trade, in particular, has been the focus of the debate for many years now and is part of the current wto negotiations.
Intraindustry trade and revealed comparative advantage. Revealed comparative advantage and competitiveness. The paper also analyses comparative advantage according to factor intensity. Balassa 1965 comparative advantage by sector of industry, brazil 19862001 marcandreas muendler. Balassa index or revealed comparative advantage, rca. In order to figure out this, data were extracted from the international trade centre itcs trade map, the unctad comtrade database and central bank of sudan. Trade reform,exports,and economic growth for decades, researchers have been debating the. Trade, competitiveness and revealed comparative advantage. This paper provides an analysis of balassas revealed comparative advantage rca. Because of that in the world trade, only if they got comparative advantage in some kinds of goods the can benefit themselves. Blasa and white index were used to compute relative comparative and competitive advantage.
Revealed comarative advantage in trade etween the reulic of acedonia and ct. In this study, we used the revealed comparative advantage rca method to analyze the direction of changes of sudanese comparative advantages for the recent period from 2000 to 20. It shows that when using rca, it should be adjusted such that it becomes symmetric around its neutral value. Although this is a widely accepted approach to analysing trade data and comparative advantage, the definition and empirical adaptation of rca are subject to controversies and thus some alternative measures now exist. Balassa 1965 comparative advantage by sector of industry, brazil. Revealed comparative advantage and the alternatives as. Problems of strategy in developing countries with exhaustible comparative advantage. Competitiveness of pakistani fruits in the world market. The results indicated that market concentration of wool and mohair is low meaning that lesotho. Comparative advantage exists when one country has a relatively lower opportunity cost of producing a given good or.
The objective of this study is to analyse the effect of trade liberalization on economic growth in switzerland using annual data from 1990 to 2014. The lack of liberalization in labor services has been particularly costly to developing countries, whose comparative advantage lies in the export of medium and lowskilled,laborintensive services. We examine the link between preferential trade liberalization and tariffs imposed against nonmember countries for the case of caftadr. Trade liberalization and revealed comparative advantage. A theoretical evaluation of alternative trade intensity. Preferential trade agreements and unilateral liberalization. Trade integration and revealed comparative advantages of sub. Economists have long sought to explain the pattern of trade by developing international trade theories since the theory of comparative costadvantage was developed by david ricardo in the 19th century. Balassa, bela 1965, trade liberalization and revealed comparative advantage. But in the other hands, the increasing trade liberalization will shape the economy in developing countries in an unhealthy way.
In this paper, two indices of trade specialization have been employed. Balassa,bela, trade liberalisation among industrial countries, new york. By analyzing the revealed comparative advantage for 19852005, we find that. An empirical study on revealed comparative advantage. View the article pdf and any associated supplements and. Balassa 1965 comparativeadvantage indices measure revealed comparative advantage from international comparisons of exports data, and are blind to possible sources of advantage. Evidence is found that trade liberalization has helped india improve its comparative advantage in industries with medium to hightechnology content, as well as in some of the industries enjoying robust. Trade integration and revealed comparative advantages of subsaharan africa and south asian merchandize export. Trade liberalization and comparative advantage dynamics in lao pdr. The neoclassical model of trade, credited to david ricardo and john stuart mill, focuses on static gains from trade that accrue from comparative advantages in production. Trade liberalisation and revealed comparative advantage.
Revealed comparative advantage in trade between the republic of macedonia and cefta 2006 prohnitchi et al. Remaining trade barriers in industrial countries are concentrated in the agricultural products and laborintensive manufactures in which developing countries have a comparative advantage. Changing revealed comparative advantage of textile and. This paper looks at the performance of hen egg export and examines the comparative advantages indices like. Features of the organization and development of crossborder cooperation between regions. Revealed comparative advantages in service trade of. Most of free trade agreements refer to the symmetrical opening of the markets i.
148 626 81 300 141 6 373 639 924 760 482 1301 560 574 1131 212 1393 71 187 284 1371 311 521 2 736 1430 1267 382 1240 358 1 510 1230 1255 243 628 249 887 290 405 1453 905 11 271